I can not reproduce that here.

Bob should not be in the reply-all if he was not on the CC or TO list of the
message.

wrote in message
oups.com...
Hi,

I have the following strange behaviour woth Outlook on Windows 2000:

David forwards me an email, that he received from Bob.

David also CCs Jack and Jill on the same forwarded email, but Bob is
not on the CC list.

When I hit Reply all, among the receivers is Bob! (Beside David, Jack
and Jill, who should really get my reply.)

Why does Bob get on my Reply all recipient list - if he was not among
the receivers of his forwarded email, sent to me by David?

Thanks!
Nick